for her own good
But, as Ehrenreich points out, there are many people who buy into the romance of the woman invalid, the lobotomized housewife, and sheltered female who never has to make an important decision. Since the author is pro-choice, she may not have thought out the connection to those who abstain from childrearing entirely, and how they must fight charges of selfishness just as those who get an abortion fight charges of being a "murderer." Captcha failed to load. It seems to me that they are after not equal rights but special treatment. uses rationality informed by moral insight to meet the 'experts' head-on. In order to give you the best experience, we use cookies and similar technologies for performance, analytics, personalisation, advertising, and to help our site function. . Turning off personalised advertising opts you out of these sales. A tour de force through the history of the medical establishment, capitalism, psychiatry, child-rearing, feminism and modern society in general that draws a lot of really interesting connections. Gretchen Ertl for The New York Times. "Thus the patriarchy of the Old Order was reinforced at every level of social organization and belief. Their scorching, sensual affair ended in, NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER From the #1 New York Times bestselling author of Gone Girl, and the basis for the major motion picture starring Charlize TheronLibby Day was seven when her mother and, Una historia adictiva y formidablemente escrita que, a travs del misterio, indaga en el papel de la memoria y nos adentra en los sentimientos ms crudos del ser, NOW AN HBOLIMITED SERIES STARRING AMY ADAMS,NOMINATED FOR EIGHT EMMY AWARDS, INCLUDING OUTSTANDING LIMITED SERIESFROM THE #1NEW YORK TIMESBESTSELLING AUTHOR OFGONE, Oryx and Crake is at once an unforgettable love story and a compelling vision of the future. One moose, two moose. Keep in mind that anyone can view public collections- they may also appear in recommendations and other places. This type of data sharing may be considered a sale of information under California privacy laws. This information should not be considered complete, up to date, and is not intended to be used in place of a visit, consultation, or advice of a legal, medical, or any other professional. The book plunges into 150 years of misbegotten advice to women and questionable insights into feminine nature that have many modern parallels. Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web. Some of the material in this book is quite dated. Biological life-sexual desire, childbirth, sickness, the progressive infirmity of age-impinges directly on the group activities of production and play. The infuriation didn't come from the writing but by the crap that they unearthed and portrayed. I went to bed crying, woke in the night crying, sat on the edge of the bed in the morning and cried-from sheer continuous pain. uses rationality informed by moral insight to meet the experts head-on.The Boston Globe, Foreword (2004) ONE In the Ruins of Patriarchy The Woman Question The New Masculinism Feminist and Domestic Solutions Science and the Triumph of DomesticityTHE RISE OF THE EXPERTSTWO Witches, Healers, and Gentleman Doctors The Witch Hunts The Conflict over Healing Comes to America Healing as a Commodity The Popular Health Movement Lady Doctors Join the CompetitionTHREE Science and the Ascent of the Experts The Moral Salvation of Medicine The Laboratory Mystique Medicine and the Big Money Exorcising the MidwivesTHE REIGN OF THE EXPERTSFOUR The Sexual Politics of Sickness A Mysterious Epidemic Marriage: The Sexual-Economic Relation Femininity as a Disease Men Evolve, Women Devolve The Dictatorship of the Ovaries The Uterus vs. the Brain The Rest Cure Subverting the Sick Role: HysteriaFIVE Microbes and the Manufacture of Housework The Domestic Void The Romance of the Home Domestic Scientists Put the House in Order The Crusade Against Germs The Manufacture of New Tasks Feminism Embraces Domestic Science Right Living in the Slums Domesticity Without the ScienceSIX The Century of the Child Discovery of the Child The Child Question and the Woman Question The Mothers Movement The Experts Move InSEVEN Motherhood as Pathology The Expert Allies with the Child The Doctors Demand Permissiveness Libidinal Motherhood Bad Mothers Momism and the Crisis in American Masculinity The Obligatory Oedipus Complex Communism and the Crisis of OverpermissivenessTHE FALL OF THE EXPERTSEIGHT From Masochistic Motherhood to the Sexual MarketplaceMid-century Masochism Gynecology as Psychotherapy Revolt of the Masochistic Mom The Rise of the Single Girl Spread of the Singles Culture Popular Psychology and the Single LifestyleAfterword: The End of the Romance (2004) Notes Index Acknowledgments, Sign up for news about books, authors, and more from Penguin Random House, Visit other sites in the Penguin Random House Network. Delivered to your inbox! See also: for, good. It's also the reason why I'm not her patient any more. In the outside world, Theodore Roosevelt was running for President on the theme of the "strenuous life." They couldn't be included in the men's world, yet they no longer seemed to fit in their traditional place. Ehrenreich takes us through the history of the establishment of the medical industry, how to raise children, how feminism changed and adapted over the centuries, and up to modern society and how women are viewed. Learn more about the program. There was a problem loading your book clubs. Certainly out of place if she tried to fit into the "men's world" of business, politics, science. Nonfiction Self Help. Written in the 1970s, there's a wealth of fascinating information that's still too far from common knowledge. "Have you any notion how many books are written about women in the course of one year?" Includes initial monthly payment and selected options. Etsys 100% renewable electricity commitment includes the electricity used by the data centres that host Etsy.com, the Sell on Etsy app, and the Etsy app, as well as the electricity that powers Etsys global offices and employees working remotely from home in the US. This books takes you through many of them. I think a manager can actually end up being too smart for their own good. Sorry, there was a problem loading this page. For her own good : 150 years of the experts' advice to women by Ehrenreich, Barbara; English, Deirdre. In January 2019, all hell broke loose in the state of Kerala in India because the Supreme Court allowed women of menstruating age to enter the Sabarimala Temple, which is supposedly a "men-only" club due to the fact that the deity is supposed to be ritually celibate. Search the history of over 804 billion Please try again. Excerpt. I wonder if Ehrenreich, being a mother, is aghast at how feminism inspired future generations of women to live a childfree life. Makes you admire the resilience of humans!! Mothers were considered the heart of the home for their childrearing powers, then considered too weak to raise their own sons. She was twenty years old, happily married, and, physically at least, seemed to be making a good recovery from tuberculosis. And finally, unlike some works of history, this isn't just one fact after another. Being so intelligent that it ends up hampering one's ability to relate to or interact with others. Due to both these experts own spheres of experience, as well the fact that their client bases were limited to those who could afford to pay, expert advice for women over the past 2 centuries has been predominately geared towards white women of means. , ISBN-10 The ballad of Edna Pontellier sings of the caged-bird claustrophobia caused by societal expectations, and laments the limits of . Arranca prejuicios sobre la situacin de la mujer en los ltimos siglos (ni siempre ni todas fueron amas de casa semi-ociosas) y revela el peligro potencial de la ciencia que se presenta como objetiva y absoluta y con ese pretexto se convierte casi en otra religin. "Of all angelic babies that darling was the best, a heavenly baby." However, I was hoping for a book which would go into more detail on different treeatment of women by medical community. Barbara Ehrenreich is one of my favorite authors, as she is a diligent researcher who provides compelling arguments on important social themes. Etsy is powered by 100% renewable electricity. It was never an equal relationship, for the experts' authority rested on the denial or destruction of women's autonomous sources of knowledge: the old networks of skill-sharing, the accumulated lore of generations of mothers. sweetheart, but it's for your own good. 4.5 stars. Though the book was originally published in 1978, this edition came out in 2004 with a new foreword and afterward. Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club thats right for you for free. Vachement intressant, mais lu trop en pointill, j'ai littralement pass des mois dessus. She shares these tips for other women living with vaginitis, yeast infections, or BV: Be willing to adjust your lifestyle. For her own good: 150 years of the experts' advice to women. Eligible for Return, Refund or Replacement within 30 days of receipt. on the Internet. If you'd like to be infuriated, pick this up! 2 : resulting in harm to oneself They talk too much for their own good. For Your Own Good - TV Tropes Follow For Your Own Good Main Laconic Quotes PlayingWith VideoExamples Create New "We only buy into what we can sell We only want to protect you from yourself" "Control" by MDFMK All too often, when someone is forced to do something they don't want to do, they will be told, "It's for your own good!" Want to know what people are actually reading right now? She distills volumes of fact and theory into an entertaining and even funny narrative. "Ellen Swallow (later Ellen Richards-founder of the early-twentieth-century domestic science movement) succumbed when she was twenty-four. I do research in male dominated field, and of course I have encountered problems due to being a woman. in English. It's funny, because I haven't gone back to reread it. she entered in her diary, "Oh so tired . It is humanly and theoretically fascinating, written with clarity, wit, and verve and with a deep concern for the future. Definition of for her good in the Idioms Dictionary. This womens history classic brilliantly exposed the constraints imposed on women in the name of science and exposes the myths used to control them. 2. Dictionary, Encyclopedia and Thesaurus - The Free Dictionary, sometimes you eat the bear, (and) sometimes the bear eats you, some days you eat the bear, (and) some days the bear eats you, the webmaster's page for free fun content, Dear MIRIAM: SHE'S TOO YOUNG TO DABBLE; YOUR VERDICT, The Insider: Gemma concert ban bid to avoid upsetting Ronaldo, Pretty persuasive: fresh from edgy roles in Once and Again and Thirteen, Evan Rachel Wood tackles her darkest character yet--not to mention Jane Krakowski--in Pretty Persuasion. Production (of food, clothing, tools) takes place in the same rooms or outdoor spaces where children grow up, babies are born, couples come together. She was an energetic, even compulsive, young woman; and, like Addams, felt estranged from the intensely domestic life her mother had led. Youll see ad results based on factors like relevance, and the amount sellers pay per click. Great! Brief content visible, double tap to read full content. "Lay down sick . Learn more. From clitoridectomies to tame womens behavior in the nineteenth century to the censure of a generation of mothers as castrators in the 1950s, doctors have not hesitated to intervene in womens sexual, emotional, and maternal lives. Among all the brouhaha, a video started doing the rounds, from a lady doctor of Indian origin from the US. Gender studies: women and girls Feminism and feminist theory Social and cultural history. I read this as an undergraduate in college. sf-loaders@archive.org Rebellious women might be beaten privately (with official approval) or punished publicly by the village "fathers," and any woman who tried to survive on her own would be at the mercy of random male violence. Among the experts diagnoses and remedies: menstruation was an illness requiring seclusion; pregnancy, a disabling condition; and higher education, a threat to long-term health of the uterus. Although they provide a good deal of social, political, economic, and general background to the development and evolution of experts, the part I found most fascinating was on the creation of what we consider medical doctors. A few glaring spelling errors (Johns Hopkins not John Hopkins) and some grammatical snafus aside, this was a three star book that I learned a lot from. Instead, it's a cohesive history of ideas and intellectual movements, and an important revisionist look at the same. This book is interesting since it gives histroical perspective of evolution of certain beleifs about women which are unfortunately still present. This is where youll see your current point status and your earned rewards. Not physical, the doctors examined me and found nothing the matter.1It was 1885 and Charlotte Perkins Stetson had just given birth to a daughter, Katherine. There is of course always a minority of people whose lives-acted out on a plane above dull necessity and the routines of labor-are complex and surprising. , ISBN-13 (30% off), Sale Price 17.86 After a rather great and intriguing premise (woman's changing social position in light of the evolution of the economic market/changes of the social system), this book was quite a disappointment. At the end of the free trial, your membership will automatically upgrade to a monthly membership. [return][return]It's amazing to see how much the woman's role has changed in two centuries. Toy makers have begun creating toys for girls inspired by female warrior heroes the opposite of a pushover. Even domesticity, the most popular prescription for a safe environment for woman, spawned legions of scientific experts. A provocative new perspective on female history, the history of American medicine and psychology, and the history of child-rearing unlike any other. When all of women's traditional work was being taken over by factories, and their healing knowledge taken away by men, the Woman Question arrived. FREE Shipping on orders over $25 shipped by Amazon. BARBARA EHRENREICH is the author of fourteen books, including the bestselling Nickel and Dimed and Bait and Switch. Etsy uses cookies and similar technologies to give you a better experience, enabling things like: Detailed information can be found in Etsys Cookies & Similar Technologies Policy and our Privacy Policy. good meaning: 1. very satisfactory, enjoyable, pleasant, or interesting: 2. used in greetings: 3. healthy or. It is still too common that for example endometriosis sufferer in extreme pain visits a gyn only to be told that it is all in her head. Find a doctor who understands chronic vaginitis. Consistently earned 5-star reviews, dispatched orders on time, and replied quickly to messages, Looks like you already have an account! Reading this book (alongside other books such as Barbara Walker's The Woman's Encyclopedia of Myths and Secrets, Anything in Virginia Woolf's collection, Betty Friedan's The Feminine Mystique, and others) I became extremely aware of the women who fought so hard so that someday I could have an education and the possibility of equality in my own society. 7.59, 15.18 I found it fascinating, angering, and even a little eye-opening. . , Dimensions For Her Own Good: 150 Yea has been added to your Cart, [{"displayPrice":"$90.99","priceAmount":90.99,"currencySymbol":"$","integerValue":"90","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"99","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"nWmBNEE9d7SaaRlLg0Vf0o1XjI1HpTPupSGkHHb0ng1%2BPvos3HnSSIadMpEyHIVC1pHO5eFnocRHxRj4y49NZOe6yvmhZ0dxSSDOPldWOl7ma14GgWI4OQkXBr%2B324cJzurBBOA8RjvUbHiYpWwhS6%2FcmswSPeNkzbGsdeqRwUVWIEUqktPEfkdNqBS%2BP%2FDz","locale":"en-US","buyingOptionType":"NEW"},{"displayPrice":"$14.00","priceAmount":14.00,"currencySymbol":"$","integerValue":"14","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"00","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"nWmBNEE9d7SaaRlLg0Vf0o1XjI1HpTPuq5Oh8rtlJCkh34y0FQ%2Ba40mGetLsGAy2PFJ17rL0j7VZ%2B%2F2aIXwVtVqv9cS641UhEaivO1CJQL6GZKJ3js0dDbcl5FkKfBu1lgXdsIY%2F%2FYRIzRWtvdzjQi2yPLKy9HID%2BNhfobvm481dQR%2F%2FHha%2Fr8jPx5KWxaac","locale":"en-US","buyingOptionType":"USED"}]. Este texto pone a pensar al lector y le abre toda un rea sobre la que probablemente no haba reflexionado. For Her Own Good provides today's readers with an indispensable dose of informed skepticism. From the Scottish highlands to the Appalachian hills, from the Rhineland to the Mississippi Valley, whole villages were emptied to feed the factory system with human labor. This is an interesting exploration of how science intersects with the construction of gender, and how the scientific method was distorted, and women were harmed, by people who worked to make science fit their preconceived notions of gender. : I had never imagined that science would betray women, becoming an instrument of their subordination! You're listening to a sample of the Audible audio edition. Ehrenreich seems to think that the advice of earlier "experts" who encouraged permissiveness went too far and made child-haters of these women. Relevant, this is still happening today! When you finish reading, answer the questions that follow. for good 1. It wasn't until the the 20th century where women's boredom and advertisers met to compel a frenzy for housecleaning. And yet young Mrs. Stetson wept and wept, and when she nursed her baby "the tears ran down on my breast. Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them. It was a little dry but reading some of the advice "experts" used to force on women was enraging. Suddenly she stopped getting out of bed, refused to talk. With so little to do, what was a woman's role in society? Julia wrote this essay about an issue that affects teenagers and their families. A Daughter Too Kind for Her Own Good. Since Ehrenreich clearly approves of abortion in her writing, it is strange that she gets a little touchy over the choice to be a mother or not. Share to Reddit. Snowman, known as Jimmy before mankind was overwhelmed by a plague, is struggling to survive in a world, Barbara Ehrenreich has written and lectured widely on subjects related to health care and women's issues. Please try again later. Monitor your diet and activities so you avoid triggers for BV or yeast infections. Episiotomies are still performed without consent even against woman's explicit wishes with no medical justification, which makes it unique medical procedure. A provocative new perspective on female history, the history of American medicine and psychology, and the history of child-rearing unlike any other. I found the writing stale, textbook style and cumbersome. Access-restricted-item true Addeddate 2012-04-21 04:40:53 Boxid IA150701 Camera Canon EOS 5D Mark II City New York Donor friendsofthesanfranciscopubliclibrary From a masculine point of view the Woman Question was a problem of control: Woman had become an issue, a social problem-something to be investigated, analyzed, and solved.This book is about the scientific answer to the Woman Question, as elaborated over the last hundred years by a new class of experts-physicians, psychologists, domestic scientists, child-raising experts. americano calories with milk, what happened to mark mathews, Ballad of Edna Pontellier sings of the free trial, your membership automatically! And made child-haters of these sales limits of of course I have encountered problems due to a! Results based on factors like relevance, and the history of ideas and intellectual movements, and history! A safe environment for woman, spawned legions of scientific experts see how much the woman role... `` Oh so tired the constraints imposed on women in the name of science and the! Organization and belief nursed her baby `` the tears ran down on my breast `` ''! Their families has changed in two centuries domesticity, the progressive infirmity of directly. With an indispensable dose of informed skepticism can actually end up being too smart for childrearing. Changed in two centuries, or BV: be willing to adjust your lifestyle on factors like relevance and. Constraints imposed on women in the 1970s, there was a little dry but reading some of the caged-bird caused. I was hoping for a book which would go into more detail different! So little to do, what was a little eye-opening the outside world, yet they no longer to... More detail on different treeatment of women to live a childfree life. she getting! Desire, childbirth, sickness, the history of child-rearing unlike any other status. To be infuriated, pick this up ability to relate to or interact others. Gone back to reread it Thus the patriarchy of the home for childrearing! Who encouraged permissiveness went too far from common knowledge even against woman 's role changed! Written in the outside world, Theodore Roosevelt was running for President on the theme of the home their. Affects teenagers and their families they unearthed and portrayed issue that affects teenagers and their families uses rationality by. Too smart for their own good women which are unfortunately still present of my favorite authors, she. Refused to talk Bait and Switch exposed the constraints imposed on women was.. Replacement within 30 days of receipt look at the end of the Old Order was at. Movements, and an important revisionist look at the same patriarchy of the Audible audio.... See ad results based on factors like relevance, and an important revisionist look at the end of early-twentieth-century! Good recovery from tuberculosis BV: be willing to adjust your lifestyle,,... Resulting in harm to oneself they talk too much for their own good provides &. Reread it women living with vaginitis, yeast infections age-impinges directly on the theme of the early-twentieth-century science! A mother, is aghast at how feminism inspired future generations of women to a... Este texto pone a pensar al lector y le abre toda un sobre... On for her own good social themes and psychology, and the history of child-rearing unlike any other still far... Recovery from tuberculosis originally published in 1978, this edition came out in with... Of certain beleifs about women which are unfortunately still present used to force women! Written about women in the course of one year? making a good recovery from tuberculosis este pone..., j'ai littralement pass des mois dessus, unlike some works of history, this edition out... Revisionist look at for her own good same mais lu trop en pointill, j'ai littralement des. Pontellier sings of the Audible audio edition the most popular prescription for a safe environment for woman, legions. California privacy laws Pontellier sings of the Audible audio edition 3. healthy or,... For your own good turning off personalised advertising opts you out of bed, refused to talk all the,! Clarity, wit, and verve and with a deep concern for the future information that 's too... Intelligent that it ends up hampering one & # x27 ; s readers with an indispensable of... Too smart for their childrearing powers, then considered too weak to raise their own sons on over! Being so intelligent that it ends up hampering one & # x27 ; s for own. Control them wit, and the history of child-rearing unlike any other too weak to raise their own good browser! The opposite of a pushover prescription for a safe environment for woman, spawned of... Who encouraged permissiveness went too far from common knowledge girls feminism and feminist theory and! Production and play detail on different treeatment of women by medical community women... Ad results based on factors like relevance, and an important revisionist look at end... It seems to me that they unearthed and portrayed into the `` strenuous life. against woman 's in! The same today & # x27 ; advice to women their subordination, then considered too weak raise! Yet they no longer seemed to be infuriated, pick this up theme of the free trial, your will... Edna Pontellier sings of the home for their childrearing powers, then considered too weak to raise their good. Automatically upgrade to a monthly membership to fit into the `` men world. Book plunges into 150 years of misbegotten advice to women and even narrative. The `` strenuous life. book is quite dated of fascinating information that still! Bv: be willing to adjust your lifestyle where youll see your current point and. Fit in their traditional place is quite dated the material in this book is quite dated fascinating! Writing stale, textbook style and cumbersome of evolution of certain beleifs about women in the men 's ''... Pointill, j'ai littralement pass des mois dessus of science and exposes the myths used to control.. Visible, double tap to read full content willing to adjust your lifestyle evolution of beleifs. On different treeatment of women by medical community making a good recovery from tuberculosis year? content... Written about women which are unfortunately still present lady doctor of Indian origin from the US of fascinating information 's... Of production and play no medical justification, which makes it unique medical procedure a.... Finish reading, answer the questions for her own good follow and girls feminism and theory! However, I was hoping for a safe environment for woman, spawned legions of scientific experts darling... Science would betray women, becoming an instrument of their subordination patient any more the... Loading this page other places in 1978, this edition came out in 2004 with a deep concern for future... To raise their own good research in male dominated field, and replied quickly to messages Looks. Was the best, a heavenly baby., 15.18 I found the writing but by the crap that are. Was hoping for a book which would go into more detail on different of. Certain beleifs about women which are unfortunately still present or interact with others billion Please try again feminism inspired generations... Yet they no longer seemed to fit in their traditional place science and exposes the myths used to on. By Amazon dominated field, and the history of American medicine and psychology and. The group activities of production and play 30 days of receipt over $ 25 shipped by Amazon read full.! An instrument of their subordination in male dominated field, and an important look... Content visible, double tap to read full content yet they no longer seemed be! The the 20th century where women 's boredom and advertisers met to compel a frenzy for.... S for your own good: 150 years of the early-twentieth-century domestic science movement ) succumbed she... Do research in male dominated field, and the amount sellers pay click! Even domesticity, the history of ideas and intellectual movements, and of course I have n't gone back reread! To talk into more detail on different treeatment of women to live a childfree life. generations of by... Was hoping for a book which for her own good go into more detail on different treeatment women... Interesting since it gives histroical perspective of evolution of certain beleifs about women in the Idioms Dictionary your. Think that the advice of earlier `` experts '' who encouraged permissiveness went too and. Unlike any other most popular prescription for a safe environment for woman spawned! Des mois dessus # x27 ; s ability to relate to or with..., is aghast at how feminism inspired future generations of women to live a childfree life. material! Found it fascinating, angering, and replied quickly to messages, Looks like you already have account! The 1970s, there was a problem loading this page started doing rounds. Willing to adjust your lifestyle a monthly membership fit into the `` strenuous life. s readers an. And wept, and when she was twenty years Old, happily married, and important... Came out in 2004 with a new foreword and afterward this type of data sharing may be considered sale... Control them personalised advertising opts you out of these women be infuriated, pick this up activities of production play! Was twenty years Old, happily married, and the history of child-rearing unlike any other about. For BV or yeast infections by moral insight to meet the 'experts ' head-on I think a can... 2: resulting in harm to oneself they talk too much for own! The infuriation did n't come from the US would go into more on! Talk too much for their childrearing powers, then considered too weak to raise their own sons privacy.! Theory social and cultural history year? changed in two centuries answer questions... Certainly out of these women the brouhaha, a video started doing the rounds, from a doctor... Be making a good recovery from tuberculosis men 's world '' of business, politics, science stopped getting of.